Electron beam melting (EBM) is one of the important powder bed fusion (PBF) processes to fabricate metallic part.^1-4 A PBF process using a plasma electron beam has been proposed recently.^4-6 The EBM process involves sequential steps of preheating and melting during each deposition of powder layer to form three-dimensional components in a layer-by-layer manner.² However, the component fabricated by EBM process may contain residual porosity internally due to insufficient time for densification of melted powder.^2,7,8 Besides, the surface of melted layer is rough.^9-11 The presence of pores and surface roughness impose detrimental effect on the mechanical properties of the fabricated component. In order to improve the quality of surface finish and mechanical properties of the fabricated part, re-melting process is carried out.^12,13

Focused plasma electron beam is applied to re-melt the deposited powder layer at a constant thickness of layer. AlMangour et al. investigated the scanning strategies of a PBF process experimentally and revealed that re-melting process reduces surface roughness and number of pores formed between scan tracks.¹² In order to control the re-melting process such that it does not excessively re-melt the deposited layer, investigation of influence of travel speed of table and thickness of deposited part on re-melting characteristics is required. Process modeling using finite element analyses (FEAs) provides a convenient solution and total quantification of thermal characteristics for investigation of a PBF process.¹⁴

Zäh and Lutzmann simulated an EBM process to estimate appropriate process window based on length-to-width ratio of molten pool.¹⁵ Ning et al. developed an analytical model to estimate the temperature of single-track and multi-track scans of a PBF process.¹⁴ Foteinopoulos et al. evaluated the temperature history of parts fabricated in PBF using two-dimensional finite difference method.¹⁶ Shen and Chou studied the influence of powder with different porosities on temperature distributions and size of molten pool using a thermal finite element analysis (FEA) of EBM.¹⁷ Cheng and Chou obtained the relationship of process parameters on geometry of molten pool for a EBM process using thermal FEA model and multi-variable regression method.¹⁸ The scanning speed of electron beam is an important parameter in EBM that affect the built quality such as porosity.^7,15 However, these investigations were limited to melting process of laid powder layer instead of re-melting process of solidified layer.

A novel metal additive manufacturing process was proposed by Ahn and Lee that applied a re-melting process based on their melting process parameters.⁶ In their process, a powder layer of 0.5 mm thick is laid, preheated, melted and re-melted using a plasma electron beam to form a deposited layer of nearly 0.5 mm.⁶ Table that holds the specimen is moved relative to a fixed plasma electron beam. In order to improve the re-melting process, the effect of re-melting process parameters on the formation of melted pool should be investigated.

In this study, heat transfer analysis for a plasma electron beam re-melting process is proposed to estimate appropriate process parameters for the novel metal additive manufacturing process proposed by Ahn and Lee.⁶ This is achieved by examining the effects of travel speed of table and thickness of deposited part on temperature distributions and formation of re-melted pool. Based on the estimated dimensions of re-melted pool using FEAs, appropriate process parameters such as travel speed of table and hatch distance between re-melting tracks are proposed for the plasma electron beam re-melting process.

In this study, a plasma electron beam re-melting system irradiates electron beam with power of 160 W on the specimen, which is attached to a moving table. In order to investigate the appropriate re-melting process parameters, a symmetrical three-dimensional thermal finite element model is developed, as shown in Fig. 1. Simulation of single track re-melting process using electron beam is simulated along the symmetry plane using moving heat source in Abaqus. The heat from plasma electron beam is modelled as volumetric heat flux with Gaussian distribution, given in Eq. (1).¹⁷

Fig. 1 
Model of FEA

Table 1 lists the parameters applied in the thermal FEAs. The heat transfer analyses are carried out according to different travel speeds of table and thickness of deposited part. The effective diameter of heat flux is approximated from experiment. The penetration depth of heat flux is assumed as the thickness of laid powder.¹⁷

The deposited part and substrate are constructed using solid 8-node linear heat transfer elements. The materials for the substrate and the deposited part are SM45C steel and Stellite21 alloy, respectively. Unlike powder layer in melting process, the deposited part in re-melting process is assumed as solid in FEA because the porosity within the deposited part is small and its effect on thermal diffusivity can be neglected. Temperature dependent thermal diffusivity of solid SM45C steel and Stellite21 alloy are applied in the model of FEAs, as shown in Fig. 2.^19-22 The melting temperature of SM45C steel and Stellite21 are 1,520°C and 1,295°C, respectively.

Fig. 2 
Temperature dependent thermal diffusivity of SM45C steel and Stellite21 alloy^19-22

The plate is preheated before re-melting process is performed. The initial temperature for plate and heat sink temperature are assumed to be 150°C and 25°C, respectively. The re-melting process requires a low pressure air environment for the plasma electron beam to operate properly.⁴ Thus, the coefficient of convection from the substrate and deposited part to the surrounding of low pressure air is assigned as 1.0W/m² × K.²³ Heat loss via radiation on the deposited part is estimated using Stefan-Boltzmann’s law. Temperature dependent emissivity of Stellite21 alloy is applied.²⁴ Thickness of deposited part is assumed to remain unchanged after re-melting process.

In this paper, the influences of different travel speeds of table and thicknesses of deposited part on temperature distributions and formations of molten pool during re-melting process were investigated using FEAs in order to select appropriate process parameters for a plasma electron beam re-melting process. From the results of heat transfer FEAs, it was revealed that temperature distributions of deposited part were affected by travel speed of table and thickness of deposited part. The formation of molten pool was estimated from the temperature distribution using melting temperatures of deposited part and substrate. The depth and width of molten pool changed according to thickness of deposited part and converged when thickness of deposited part is greater than 2.5 mm.

Based on the above results, the appropriate travel speeds of table between 5 to 10 mm/s were suggested for the plasma electron beam re-melting process. The hatch spacing between re-melting tracks based on converged width of molten pool was determined to be appropriate process parameters for the plasma electron beam re-melting process. The suggested range of travel speeds of table is coincident with the travel speed of 5 mm/s applied for a proper deposition and re-melting process in the novel metal additive manufacturing by Ahn and Lee.⁶ However, they derived the hatch spacing of 1 mm based on the width of single deposition bead.⁶ The re-melting process in the novel metal additive manufacturing can be accelerated by applying the proposed hatch spacing between re-melting tracks because the proposed hatch spacing is 2.6 times larger as compared to those applied by Ahn and Lee at travel speed of 5 mm/s.

In the future, re-melting process using the suggested process parameters should be performed experimentally to validate the results of FEAs. In order to further improve the re-melting process, the effect of power and effective diameter of electron beam on the formation of re-melting pool can be considered via experiment and numerical analysis to obtain a desired wide and shallow re-melted pool.